O
Hello OpenStreetMap community, We’re writing to announce an upcoming organized editing project by Uber focused on improving pedestrian-related map data in Turkiye. As an initial phase, we plan to focus on Antalya city,Turkiye. The goal of this project is to improve pedestrian map data in and around Antalya city to support more accurate pedestrian navigation that will allow our users to find their riders safer and more efficiently. In the spirit of transparency and collaboration, we have…
O
MitteloberrheinischerWaldameisenschreck: Ich verstehe den tieferen Sinn der left/right/no/sep.-Feingranularität nicht … bicycle=use_sidepath cycleway=separate Ich geh halt nach DE:Bicycle/Radverkehrsanlagen kartieren - OpenStreetMap Wiki und da steht in den Beispielen cycleway:right=separate. Der tiefere Sinn des Taggings ist mir an mehreren Stellen in dieser Doku nicht klar, z.B. vehicle=no in Fahrradstraßen und bicycle=designated bei hw=cycleway. Im Vergleich zu diesen beiden Beispielen hat…
O
Estos son algunos comentarios sobre la traducción en diferentes canales de Telegram: Argentina - Telegram: View @osm_ar (4 likes más otros 2 en otra respuesta). Cuba - Telegram: View @OSM_Cuba (1 comentario positivo). México - Telegram (3 likes). Colombia - Telegram: View @osmco (1 comentario positivo). Panamá - Telegram: View @Comunidad_OSM_Panama (1 comentario de traducción). Bolivia - Telegram: View @osmbolivia (1 like). Dado que hay varias opiniones, sugiero que hagamos una encuesta, con…
O
This is true. It does not just apply to ruins though. Renderers should (ideally) support all of construction:building=, disused:building=, abandoned:building=, and ruined:building. They all have functional implications for the building (ie. you wouldn’t want to be misled by thinking a shelter thats under construction will be functional if you’re caught in the rain) but they should all be rendered.
O
kitsee: This all leads me on to another question. how should amenity=fuel areas be mapped? until now I’ve understood it to be only the area immediately around the pumps where vehicles stop to refuel. Should we be mapping it as additional area overlapping the roof area or should we use the entire forecourt and if so where does the forecourt begin and end. Or do we use arbitrary area somewhere in between. I think one of the causes of this whole issue is that the area of amenity=fuel is not well…
O
I agree that it can be tedious. With a mind to accessibility though, there is a world of difference between “There is not an inch of tactile paving in this whole city” and “nobody has ever thought to check if any of these curbs have tactile paving”. I like that StreetComplete asks. Knowing that StreetComplete has quests for this (as well as surface=*) has actually changed how I map so I fill out these values much more frequently when my imagery is clear enough to tell.
O
confusedbuffalo: I thought it was obvious that you don’t get petrol out of a roof, but seemingly other people disagree with me… This is unfortunately the fundamental issue. Just because something appears obvious to one person does in no way guarantee that it is correct, or standard, or warranted, or desired. I would encourage all mappers who feel they have found a large-scale issue to first raise it with the community so that it can be inspected, discussed and acted upon with the combined…
O
Thank you for writing this very detailed breakdown of some of the various issues that have arisen in the UK over the last few years, which in many cases could have been prevented if the users and groups involved were more proactive about seeking discussion or approval before starting their edits or projects. These examples highlight that requiring a discussion before automated, large or organised edits is not just an arbitrary rule but exists to help minimise outcomes such as these. The…
O
Hola @Hannah_Evans, gracias por tu aporte. En ese sentido, iD ya cubre buena parte de lo que propones: al presionar el botón de información (i) del preset, se muestra la descripción tomada de la wiki, e incluye la foto como ejemplo, que en este caso es una casa, lo que ayuda a entender que la etiqueta no se limita a construcciones grandes (como se ve en la captura que adjunto). Además, iD soporta sinónimos de búsqueda en los presets, y el preset de Edificio ya incluye términos como…
O
Marcos_Dione: The default osm-carto style already does this: Thanks Marcos. Yes, OSM Carto’s grain was the inspiration for this work, and the article credits it. It also took about nine years to land (requested in 2014, shipped in 5.7.0 in 2023), which is why a shared convention that other maps can pick up seems worth writing down. Marcos_Dione: Current boolean function deciding un/paved: This is where I’d do things differently. The function lists unpaved values and paved values, and anything…
O
Ciao ragazzi, è da un po’ che la addocchio ma oggi mi son detto “mappo quella strada che ha un cartello che non ho mai visto usare”. Quel cartello è un cartello giallo con scritto “STRADA NON COLLAUDATA” che pensavo sarebbe stato tolto pochi mesi dopo averlo visto per la prima volta. sono ovviamente passati tipo 2 anni ed eccolo sempre presente. Non si vede niente perchè è notte ed il mio smartphone fa schifo ma è quello centrale nella foto. La trovate a Way: Via Castagna (1259275163) |…
O
Makes sense that it’s mainly a US tag. The only real description of it I’ve found was in the mapping guide for the US OpenSidewalks project. I’m pretty split about putting a bunch of ‘no’ values everywhere. On one hand, I like being able to see that someone (usually myself in the areas I map) has checked for the presence of some feature. On the other hand, it can feel messy to slap tactile_paving=no on dozens of kerbs
O
Those are the main flaws of the proposal. In botany you have trees, plants growing on trees. Plants growing below trees and growing around them. Flowers, fern,… growing besides them. Grass, mosses growing below those… I mean, it’s not endless, but it’s quite a lot. On top of that, depending on the region, not all of them are present in all seasons. Take a look at a park. Mainly has grass, but there are some scattered trees. So do I need to exclude the area covered by the trees from the…
O
Yes, but nor does the brand tag transcribe the sign. We don’t tag brand:en=Starbucks Coffee nor brand:fr=Café Starbucks, it’s all brand=Starbucks
O
flohoff: “Good, Fast, Cheap. Pick any two, you cant have all three” Genau… und jeder Router kann das beliebig wählen und ich sehe keinen Grund warum OSM nicht jede Kombination unterstützen sollte. Wenn stündliche Graphänderungen für “dich” nichts ist, ist das ok. OSMand bietet stündlich ein Update. Die müssen aber auch nur mich auf meinem Smartphone bespielen mit der Rechnenleistung dieses Gerätes. Wenn TomTom das unter ähnlichen Hardwarevorraussetzungen und vermutlich größerem Budget nicht…
O
I’ve had a look through most of the changes south of the Humber, and they seem to be largely correct. I’m not sure what the sources are for some parts, for example the new roads on Highfields Development in Immingham are correct, but I’m not aware of any maps or imagery that include it all yet (open or otherwise), so I wonder if some parts have been surveyed. On the other hand, the water main that passed through that development had been diverted in the changes, but in reality the new…
O
OK! Changed to “permissive.” We and the neighbors are indeed a bit concerned because there is a proposal to use this connecting trail as a portion of a town “greenway” connecting various town open spaces. Even though we applaud the initiative, we have concerns for the connecting trail to be be labeled as a PUBLIC portion of the greenway.
O
The sign is in both languages. The operator / brand tagging does not imply service in any given language.
O
One small point: don’t think you need to ‘speculate’ on expanding abbreviated destinations, because the Dept for Transport actually prescribes an official list of trunk destinations, so you can reliably expand any abbreviated one to its full name - see the Sabre Roads site Making sure you're not a bot! for more info on this
O
access=no means that even the property owners don’t have access. I’m guessing that’s probably not accurate, so you should use access=private instead. Though if the sign you referenced “Private property. Use trail respectfully and at own risk.” is still present then I actually think access=permissive is the correct classification. While you have a right to decide who is allowed on your property, you don’t necessarily have a right to control how information about that decision gets disseminated,…
O
Das nicht, auch nicht für den Router (mit fragwürdigen Angaben). Aber helfen können wir beiden, solange die Einträge OSM-konform sind.
O
We actually want to keep this section of the trail private since we created it to give us access from our private properties to the town’s open spaces on either end of it.
O
All Trails had suggested we come here and mark the trail private. Then we saw the option to mark it as “no.” This option more closely aligns with how we and our neighbors feel about how we want to publicly define this access trail - one which we created from our private properties to the town open spaces. Although we have been comfortable with our neighborhood dog walkers using the connection trail to complete an approx 2 mile loop through it and the neighboring open spaces, we have become…
O
We have changesets that cover continents. But also tiny changesets that can be Mass edits too. With new mobile tools, I see a lot of changesets with one object edited at the time. If we can’t stop this, let’s find ways to analyze this. Tools such as OSMCha or osm-suspicious or other monitoring tools could add a Synthetised view of changesets grouping together these tiny changesets with the same type of edit. And why not, AI could help us to categorize and present changesets patterns. OSMCha…
O
But disadvantage is fact that building tagged as “abandoned:building=\*” will not appear on rendered maps unless support for this tag is explicitly included. Foundations of buildings can be tagged as man_made=foundation ( Tag:man_made=foundation - OpenStreetMap Wiki ). Follies also can be tagged as building=folly ( Tag:building=folly - OpenStreetMap Wiki ) or man_made=folly.
O
Hi everyone! My name is Sofía, and I am the OSM Curation Policy Lead at Lyft. We are trying to find the correct tagging format for destination signs on UK roads. We are seeing quite a few differences from how roads are signed (and tagged) in the US, and we haven’t been able to find any UK-specific guidance on this. The only guidance we found is that the UK tries to follow the global destination tagging scheme (wiki). These are a few observations I’ve made: ref Motorway numbers are usually used,…
O
limes11: Falls der offizielle Name im Impressum der Webseite davon abweicht, sollte dies unter official_name gehen, nicht unter name. Ja. Grundsätzlich ist jede Art werblicher Hervorhebung seitens OSM unerwünscht. Dazu zählen Namen, die das Dienstleistungsangebot in epischer Breite auf die Karte zu klatschen versuchen (das “Aparthotel Bayerischer Hof - Wellness und Spa” mag sich zwar so in die Gelben Seiten eintragen, bei uns heisst es nur “Bayerischer Hof”) oder auch typografische Experimente…
O
z.B. Route grid die 5 Routen (z.B. Route 163047: L 551 Königsallee to L 654 Essener Straße) über die Wilhelm-Stumpf-Str. Die kommen alle von node “L 551 Königsallee (6840)”. Das scheint ein Grenzfall zu sein und davon abzuhängen, ob an dieser Kreuzung OpenStreetMap Richtung Nordwesten (z.B. Route 163047: L 551 Königsallee to L 654 Essener Straße) oder Südwesten (z.B. Route 163028: L 551 Königsallee to K 10 Krayer Straße ) geroutet wird. Da ist auch nichts kaputt, da grundsätzlich von Yorckstr.…
O
Voonosm: not visible at all other than knowing where to go and watch spots, as highway=scramble? Weil mir gerade danach ist, ich hab den tag erfunden. Und ein RfC gestartet und irgendwann dann ein Vote. Die Wahl ging mit absoluter Mehrheit aus, aber nicht den verlangten 75% für ein Approval. Die Idee war, etwas Nachprüfbares zu Grunde zu legen: Brauch ich da die Hände, wenn ich durch will? Was so einfach scheint, in OSM ist das sehr kompliziert, weil OSM mappern nicht zugetraut werden kann,…
O
Wo siehst du das? Beispiel? Im Grid view - also da wo du die Sammlung aller routen siehst kannst du jedes segmen anwählen und bekommst 5 Beispielrouten. Das können mitunter aber hunderte sein auf bestimmten segmenten - ich zeige da nur links zu den ersten 5. Und die Wahl der Knoten kann nicht “Unglücklich” sein. Wenn Start und Ziel auf dem Höherwerten Straßennetz ist - sollte es die Route auch komplett sein. Darum geht es genau. Wenn die Route eine Secondary verlässt um durch ein Wohngebiet auf…