XIO

xWire

Posts from every feed QUEST has found across the web — blogs, news, podcasts, channels and more.

Shopify Developer Community Forums - Topics tagged app-store

Topics tagged app-store

Submission Limited: Potential issue when developing more than one app

Hey all, First off, I think the new submission limits are a great idea (providing people don’t just buy installs to get around them!). Anything that potentially makes the App Store better for merchants works for me. However, I think I’ve come across a potential issue. I currently have two apps in development, neither of which has been submitted yet. I’m wanting to submit one of them shortly, but I’ve noticed something a bit strange. One of the apps is flagged as “Submission Limited”, while the…

New Code of Conduct Rule

How Can Shopify Stop App Store Spam and Unfair Competition? Shopify App Store Hey all – I’ve hidden a bunch of posts from this topic. I’ve added a new rule to the Code of Conduct which I am also including here: Report Partner Violations Through the Appropriate Channels If you believe another Shopify Partner or their app has violated Shopify’s terms or policies, submit a report through the Report a Partner violation form for review by Partner Governance. Include relevant evidence in your report…

IP allowlist (Nov 20): what’s been answered since the announcement - and the part I think matters more than the deadline

The allowlist deadline (this Friday, Nov 20, 11:59 PM ET) has been covered to death, so I won’t re-explain it. What I keep coming back to is less the single deadline and more the stack it belongs to. Quick status if you’re still catching up: Nov 20 - public apps calling the Admin API without an allowlist get delisted, blocked from new installs, and flagged in Settings > Apps Apr 1, 2027 - Admin API requests actually start failing (existing installs keep working until then) Two things genuinely…

Sales Channel review stuck for months: conflicting guidance, fixes submitted, cooldown still enforced

Hi everyone, Has anyone successfully escalated a prolonged Sales Channel review to someone who could resolve conflicting guidance and coordinate a retest? I’m Marcel, founder of Outfino, a Hungarian Startup with approximately 15,000 users. We’ve been working through this process since June, across multiple review and remediation rounds. Here’s the history: June 27: Support reviewed our proposed multi-merchant cart, single Stripe payment and off-platform commission settlement, and told us…

The app recommendations in Sidekick create an unfair competitive environment among apps

Shopify is fundamentally changing how users interact with apps and discover them by introducing Sidekick and making it a major focus. At the same time, this is directly impacting apps ranked fourth and below, as well as apps that are actively running ads. I’ve noticed a significant decline in traffic to my app and, consequently, in installations since Sidekick was introduced. It seems that Shopify is focusing heavily on adopting new technologies without sufficiently considering the long-term…

First app under the new 10-install rule: how did you get your first 10 paid installs?

Hi all, I’m a solo developer about to submit my first app, a free storefront app, under the new rule that each listed app needs 10 installs from paid-plan stores before you can list another. I’d like to hear from developers who launched a new app recently: With no existing audience, how long did your newest app take to reach 10 installs from paid-plan stores? Which channels brought those first installs? For example App Store search, YouTube how-to videos, your own website or free tools, or blog…

Where can we see qualifying install counts for the new app submission limits?

Just a quick one! With the new app submission limits (i.e. needing at least 10 installs on each of my existing apps), is there somewhere I can see the exact install counts that count towards this requirement? Most of my apps have significantly more than the required 10 installs, but a few of my more niche apps have slightly fewer. The confusing bit is that the Dev Dashboard shows more than 10 installs for these apps, so I’m assuming it’s including development store installs, which don’t count…

Custom-distributed standalone OAuth app fails when clicking Install — no callback or installation events

Hi Shopify developers, We’re developing a non-embedded, API-only app for a single Shopify merchant store using custom distribution and the legacy authorization-code OAuth flow. Configuration: App created within a Shopify Partner organisation Custom distribution restricted to one store Scopes: write_products, write_files, read_inventory, read_locations HTTPS callback registered in the active released version Server-side OAuth initiation through a local /connect handler What works: Our…

Non Compliant 1 Star Review, 8 months active

Here the review, it’s obviously non compliant as it’s written there. Manage app reviews in the Shopify App Store Inappropriate content: The review contains swearing, slurs, or threats. I opened multiple tickets since, nothing changed or even get a return per mail. Also the review is mostly a lie as our app is a freemium and he just got the limit of it which mean the widget was not appearing anymore. 3 posts - 2 participants Read full topic

Shopify’s new rules clean up App Store spam, finally addressing the store’s biggest problem

Shopify changed the App Store submission rules this week (live Nov 10), aimed straight at low-effort listings. The store’s been pulling in around 85 new apps a day lately, and plenty of devs were sitting on dozens of listings with almost no installs. The new rules: Can’t list a new app unless each existing app has 10+ installs on paid, active stores Identity verification required to submit Cooldowns get longer with each rejected submission No installs after 6 months, and the app gets moved back…

App Review rejections

Reference: 134323 I’m hoping someone from Shopify can help me out. My app just had it’s second review rejected. The reviewer wasn’t following the testing instructions and went off-script. The reviewer was attempting to test hiding their “Free Shipping” shipping rate. They were using product tags for a condition, but they never showed their product in the screencast. I believe their product didn’t have the product tag they entered, so it didn’t work. The tag they entered was the product name, so…

Embedded app: signed storefront monitoring up to the checkout handoff. Is this within the rules?

Hi everyone, We’re building a feature for our embedded Shopify app and want to confirm it complies with the Partner Program Agreement, the App Store requirements and the crawler access rules before we ship it. What the feature does Our app is a cart drawer. In response to the recent checkout hijack incidents, we’re adding a feature to reassure merchants that their customers actually end up in their Shopify checkout. Merchants will be able to use the feature to schedule synthetic checks of their…

A Concern About Review Gating

Are Shopify App Store Reviews Really Fair? I’ve been wondering how certain Shopify apps are getting so many positive reviews every day while the rest of us struggle to collect genuine feedback, even when we actively ask merchants for reviews. Recently, I noticed something concerning with an app called ProductUpload.ai. It first shows merchants a pop-up asking whether they like the app. Only when merchants respond positively are they redirected to Shopify’s official review system. Those who are…

"Shopify has deemed this app as a connector app." (but it's not)

Hi everyone, My app submission was paused because Shopify classified it as a Connector App under Section 2.3.19. As I understand it, this classification applies to apps whose primary purpose is transferring merchant data to third parties. However, my app’s primary purpose is collection merchandising (sorting products positions, composing collections), not data transfer. It does offer an optional MCP integration that allows merchants to talk to the app/manage app settings and configurations…

Does Unpublishing Apps with Fewer Than 10 Installs Restore Eligibility to Submit New Apps?

Hi Shopify Team, I’d like to clarify the new 10-install requirement for submitting additional apps. If a developer has several published apps, and some have fewer than 10 qualifying installs, can they unpublish or sunset those underperforming apps and then submit a new app for review? Specifically, once those apps are officially unpublished by Shopify Support, will they be excluded from the 10-install requirement? Or will previously published apps continue to count toward the submission limit…

My Shopify Apps Delisted without any warning or Violation Concerns

Hey all, I am not sure whether I can get the solution for my Shopify apps here or not. But I am posting this maybe someone from the Shopify team take a look and resolve this issue. Especially @Alan_G can help with this matter. I am Qasim. I am running multiple apps in different organization but the apps that are delisted today without any warning are the 5. I got the email from Shopify Governance team that they found the violation in my partner account (violation not explained) and they delist…

Updates to App Store submission requirements: build, grow, then expand

Hi everyone, We’re updating App Store submission requirements to help keep the App Store a place merchants can trust. The core idea is simple: build an app that delivers value, grow its adoption, then expand. Before adding more apps to the App Store, partners should validate that their existing apps are delivering value to merchants. What’s changing Establish adoption - Before you list an additional app, your existing apps need to show real merchant demand. Partners will need to reach at least…

Before BFCM: new Shopify app reviews fell 13% in 30 days, and most arrive on day one or after 2+ months

I looked at the last 30 days of App Store reviews (Oct 11 - Nov 10) ahead of BFCM. New reviews are falling: 22,577 new reviews still live, down 13% vs the previous 30 days 9,216 reviews removed in the same window, down 5% 1-2 star share flat at 2.7% The part that seemed more useful for BFCM is when those reviews get written, measured by how long the merchant had used the app before reviewing: Under 1 day: ~3,950 (about 1 in 6) 1 day to 2 months: ~6,300 combined (about 28%) Over 2 months:…

App Review Delays

I am one of many trying to get my new app approved and stuck on the “We’re assigning a reviewer to your submission” status for weeks. I would love to know how many are currently pending! Come on Shopify share! Shopify needs to separate those apps designed by AI and those designed by developers who have spent many hours building our apps. 4 posts - 3 participants Read full topic

fontSize on s-heading / s-text is stripped in App Home UI extension

I’m building an App Home UI extension (admin.app.home.render, api_version = "2026-10", Preact) for a custom-distribution app. I’m trying to show a large number on a dashboard, but the admin removes the fontSize and fontWeight properties before rendering. The Heading docs for 2026-10 list fontSize with values up to large-400, and Text lists fontSize up to large-100. What I wrote: <s-stack direction="block" gap="small-200"> <s-text color="subdued">Paid members</s-text> <s-heading…

COD form rejected for bypassing checkout, is there a policy difference for existing apps?

Hi everyone, I’m Yoiner, the developer behind Trya, a COD form app for Latin American merchants. Our submission was paused under requirements 1.1.2 (Use Shopify checkout) and 1.1.7 (Payment Gateway apps). In our COD flow, the customer fills out a form and the app creates an order with payment pending. We don’t collect card details or charge the customer in this flow. Payment is collected on delivery. I understand the reviewer’s explanation. What I’m struggling to understand is how this…

App stuck in repeated review failures for 4 months - how can we break the cycle?

We’ve been trying to get our Shopify app (Smartix) through review for four months, and I’m struggling to find a way forward. The app has been functionally complete for months, but we’ve now experienced four rejections, none of which has resulted from a demonstrated defect in our application. In three reviews, installation steps appear not to have been completed correctly. In another, I reproduced the reported failure on the day of rejection, but the problem had disappeared the following day,…

DMCA for a lookalike App Store icon closed in one minute as "not hosted by Shopify"

I build Stockful, an inventory app on the App Store. On November 6 a new app, Stockproof Inventory Stocktake, launched in the same inventory category with an icon that closely resembles mine: the same orange isometric cube in the same orientation and colour scheme on a dark rounded square, with a gradient and corner brackets added. Add the “Stock” name and the same category, and merchants could easily assume the two apps are connected. This morning I filed a copyright notice through Shopify’s…

Identify Sidekick installs in the shopify_app_install GA4 event

Hi folks, installs from Sidekick (and from the listing’s /install link) reach GA4 as shopify_app_install with no source. In GA4 they look the same as installs where the merchant declined cookies on the listing. Now that Sidekick is a real discovery channel, we can’t measure it. Could Shopify add a parameter such as install_source to the event, with values like sidekick, install_link and app_store? It needs no merchant data, only where the install came from. This was asked when Sidekick…

Shopify App Submission Blocked by “Submission Limited” Error

Hi, We already have a published public app on the Shopify App Store, currently installed on 3 active stores under the Pay-as-You-Go plan. However, when trying to submit another app, we receive the “Submission limited” error. Why are we facing this restriction despite already having a public app with active installations? How can we get this limitation removed? Thanks! 7 posts - 6 participants Read full topic

Shopify Embedded App Redirect Loop After Deployment (/app → /auth/login → /)

Hi everyone, We are experiencing an intermittent ERR_TOO_MANY_REDIRECTS issue in our Shopify embedded app, mainly after deployments or when an older tab remains open. We identified a redirect cycle involving our root and login routes and would like to confirm the recommended handling. Environment React Router: 7.13.1 (Framework Mode, lazy route discovery) @shopify/shopify-app-react-router: 1.1.1 @shopify/shopify-api: 12.3.0 @shopify/app-bridge-react: 4.2.4 React / React DOM: 18.3.1 Node.js:…

Suggestion for unlisted app exemption for new App Store submission rule

I just noticed there’s a new rule of existing apps must have at least 10 paid installs, before allowing to submit new app, in the launch guidelines : Submit your app for review I understand Shopify’s motivation to stop mass submission of apps, and agree this is a good direction. I would like to suggest to allow exemption for Unlisted public apps, there’s scenarios where devs create unlisted public apps to serve their existing clients, perhaps clients with multiple stores but not on Plus yet…